Hey, and welcome back to my humble little website, where I talk about food and all its quirks and strangeness. This song reminded me of something I believe we can all relate to. That one dish or food that instantly puts a smile on your face, like an enthusiastic cheerleader jumping up and down just for you. Just like OMI sang about.
For some, it might be your mother’s pasta, a friend’s tacos, or a signature dish made by a passionate chef. It’s different for everyone, but they all have something in common: they make us happy in their own little ways.
But why is that? Why can certain foods give us that sudden little mood boost, sometimes before we’ve even taken a bite? Well, that’s what I want to find out. And you’re more than welcome to come along!

My Own Little Food Cheerleaders
Okay, now let’s talk about my own food cheerleaders, the foods that can light up my mood almost instantly. And here’s the weird thing about me. I don’t have just one, two, or even three of these little pick-me-ups, like some people might have. For me, it all depends on the mood I’m in.
Sometimes a hamburger can put a big smile on my face. Other times, it’s a home-cooked meal that reminds me of home or my younger years. And sometimes it’s something I’ve never even tried before, passionately prepared by someone who’s excited to share it with me.
So, I’m not really attached to just a couple of foods that cheer me on. There are quite a few of them, actually. Maybe I’m simply unable to make a choice, like Sofi (if you get that one, well done!), or maybe I’m just the odd one out. Who knows?
But that’s exactly why this question interests me so much. Why can certain foods suddenly make us feel happier, sometimes just by thinking about them?
Now, I want to make a little distinction here. I’m talking about that sudden happy feeling a certain food can give you, not necessarily the nostalgic memories that food can bring back. Because surely those are two different things, right?
The Party Starts Before the First Bite
Here’s something rather funny about food. You don’t even have to eat it for it to make you happy.
Just imagine walking past a bakery and suddenly catching the smell of freshly baked bread. Or you’re sitting at home, minding your own business, when the thought of a juicy hamburger pops into your head. And before you know it, there’s a little smile creeping onto your face. But why? You haven’t eaten anything yet!
Well, that’s where your brain comes into play. You see, our brains have a reward system that helps us recognize and pursue things we enjoy. And when you see, smell, or even think about a food you love, that system can already start getting excited about what’s coming.
One of the chemicals involved is dopamine. Now, dopamine often gets called the happiness chemical, but that’s a bit misleading. It’s more involved in motivation, learning, and anticipating rewards than simply making us feel happy.
In other words, your brain isn’t necessarily throwing a party because you’ve eaten something delicious. Sometimes it’s already putting up the decorations because it thinks something delicious is on its way.
Of course, sometimes your brain can get a little too excited about what’s coming. I remember a burger I ordered in Curaçao after a long, exhausting journey. I was starving, and in my head, that burger was already the best thing I’d eaten in years.
Unfortunately, the burger had other plans. It tasted like someone had accidentally emptied an entire jar of cumin into the meat. I told the full story in my cumin post, but let’s just say the food cheerleaders in my head put on a much better performance than the team on the field.
And here’s where science has a rather interesting name for what happened: reward prediction error. Basically, your brain makes a prediction about how rewarding something will be and then compares that expectation with what actually happens. When the two don’t match, your brain gets a little surprise. And that surprise can help it learn what to expect next time.
In my case, I learned to take a small test bite whenever I order a burger somewhere unfamiliar. Apparently, my brain wasn’t taking any chances with the cheerleading squad again. Talk about a disappointing halftime show!

When the Underdog Wins the Game
Now, before you start thinking that our brain’s little prediction game only leads to disappointing burgers, there’s another side to it. Sometimes the exact opposite happens. You take a bite of something without expecting much, and suddenly your taste buds are throwing a party you didn’t even know you’d been invited to.
Remember that reward prediction error we talked about? Well, it works both ways. Sometimes food turns out worse than expected, but sometimes it’s so much better that your brain gets a rather pleasant surprise. And I have a wonderful memory of exactly that happening.
Years ago, I was having a drink with a friend at a small beach bar on the French side of St. Martin. The view was absolutely gorgeous. Crystal-clear blue water, a beautiful beach, and hardly anyone around. The bar itself, however, was a different story. Let’s just say the surroundings and the smell weren’t exactly inviting.
We were getting hungry and discussing where to go for something to eat when the bartender overheard us. He immediately jumped into the conversation, telling us about this amazing steak sandwich their chef made. Perfectly balanced flavors, all the trimmings, and apparently the best steak sandwich he’d ever eaten.
Now, looking around the place, we had our doubts. Quite a few of them, actually. But the bartender was convincing. Perhaps he really believed in that sandwich, or perhaps he just didn’t want his only customers to leave. Who knows? Haha!
Anyway, we decided to take a leap of faith, ordered two steak sandwiches and another beer, and continued chatting. About fifteen minutes later, the kitchen bell rang. The bartender disappeared into the back, and suddenly the most wonderful smell came drifting our way. Roasted beef, fresh herbs, a little hint of acidity. Hang on a minute. This was promising!
Then the sandwiches arrived. They looked fantastic and smelled even better. And that first bite? WOW. Just WOW. Beautifully seasoned beef, perfectly balanced flavors, and every little ingredient seemed to know exactly what it was doing. The bartender hadn’t been exaggerating. That sandwich was absolutely delicious.
Now, here’s where things get interesting. Our expectations had been pretty low, but the actual experience was fantastic. That’s a positive reward prediction error, when something turns out better than your brain predicted.
Of course, there’s more to enjoying food than simply being surprised. The taste, aroma, texture, and even how hungry you are all play their part. Our brains combine those sensations with what we’ve learned to enjoy, helping turn a mouthful of food into a genuinely pleasurable experience.
And sometimes, as with that steak sandwich, the experience is so good that it becomes a memory you carry around for years. I still think about that sandwich occasionally. Not bad for a little beach bar we almost walked away from. Sometimes the underdog doesn’t just win the game. It leaves you cheering for an encore!
Hold On… Wasn’t Nostalgia a Different Thing?
Now, remember earlier when I said that the happy feeling certain foods give us and the nostalgic memories they bring back were two different things?
Well, it turns out I might have been a little too confident about that one. You see, our brains are rather good at connecting things. A certain smell, flavor, or dish can become associated with people, places, and experiences we’ve enjoyed. And when we encounter that food again, those associations can influence how we feel, sometimes without us even consciously thinking about the original experience.
Think about a dish your mother used to make, or something you always ate during a wonderful holiday. You might smile the moment you smell it, long before you start remembering exactly when or where you last enjoyed it.
And smell is particularly interesting here. The brain pathways involved in processing odors have close connections with areas involved in emotion and memory, including the amygdala and hippocampus. That’s one reason a familiar aroma can sometimes bring back such vivid, emotional memories.
But here’s the funny thing. Not every food cheerleader needs a nostalgic memory attached to it. Remember that steak sandwich I discovered in St. Martin? Before I tasted it, I had no wonderful childhood memory of that particular sandwich. No family tradition, no special occasion. Just a questionable beach bar, a convincing bartender, and a rather pleasant surprise. But now? That sandwich has become a happy memory of its own. And thinking about it still makes me smile.
So perhaps I was looking at this the wrong way. Nostalgia and our little food cheerleaders aren’t necessarily two completely separate things. They can overlap, but they don’t have to.
Sometimes food makes us happy because it reminds us of something wonderful. Sometimes it’s simply because we love the taste. And sometimes a completely new experience gives us a wonderful memory to look back on later.

Different Day, Different Cheerleader
So, after all this investigating, I think I’ve figured out why I have so many different food cheerleaders.
You see, what makes us happy when it comes to food isn’t always the same from one day to the next. Our mood, appetite, surroundings, and even what we’ve eaten recently can influence what sounds particularly delicious at that moment.
Sometimes we’re craving something familiar, sometimes we’re looking for a little excitement, and sometimes we’re simply hungry enough that a good hamburger sounds like the greatest invention since sliced bread. And that’s perfectly fine with me.
I don’t need to pick one favorite food to cheer me on. That would be like having an entire cheerleading squad and only letting one of them shake their pom-poms. Where’s the fun in that? And remember, sometimes the best cheerleader is the one you never saw coming!
Yohan