Let's get social!
Back

“This Is Halloween”

Growing up, Halloween was never really a thing for me. I knew what it was from television and movies, but nobody around me was turning the house into a graveyard or sending kids into the streets dressed as vampires. We had St. Maarten in the Netherlands, with kids walking around carrying little lanterns and singing at people’s doors for candy. I never joined in myself, but I knew the famous song: “Sint Maarten, Sint Maarten, de koeien hebben staarten.” Which roughly translates to: Saint Martin, Saint Martin, the cows have tails. Why the cows needed to be involved, I still don’t know.

Pumpkin wasn’t exactly fighting for attention in my childhood either. At least not in my little world. I can’t remember us eating it at home, and it was one of those vegetables or technically fruits, that felt a little exotic. My proper introduction came much later, when I started working in professional kitchens, where suddenly pumpkin was being roasted, turned into soup, mixed with herbs and spices and generally treated like it had been waiting all those years for me to finally notice it.

Halloween eventually became much more familiar to me too, and somewhere along the way those two things became almost impossible to separate. Put a carved orange pumpkin with a candle inside it on a doorstep and nobody thinks, Ah yes, lovely seasonal vegetable. They think Halloween.

But why are pumpkins associated with Halloween in the first place? Because here’s the funny part: the pumpkin wasn’t even the original star of the show. It stole the role.

why are pumpkins associated with Halloween 3 pumpkins
Image by Mayur Gadge from Pixabay

Before Halloween Got Its Hands on It

Long before anyone thought about cutting a creepy smile into a pumpkin, humans were already messing around with its ancestors. Squash from the Cucurbita family was domesticated in the Americas thousands of years ago, and some of its wild relatives were very different from the pumpkin we know today. Small, tough and sometimes intensely bitter, not exactly something that screams, roast me with some garlic.

But humans apparently looked at that and thought there was potential. Generation after generation, people selected and grew plants with traits they actually wanted: less bitterness, more edible flesh, bigger fruits and useful seeds. Slowly, those wild plants became the enormous variety of squash and pumpkins we have today.

I find that fascinating. We sometimes talk about fruits and vegetables as if nature handed us a finished supermarket collection, but humans have been interfering with the menu for a very long time. The pumpkin sitting in the vegetable aisle isn’t simply something we discovered. In a way, it’s something generations before us helped create.

And after thousands of years of turning it into food, we eventually decided the obvious next step was to hollow it out, cut a face into it and put a candle inside. Humans are wonderfully strange like that.

Why Are Pumpkins Associated With Halloween?

Before the pumpkin got the job, people in Ireland and parts of Britain were carving things like turnips and other root vegetables. Faces were cut into them, a light could be placed inside, and different traditions and stories became connected to them. One of the best-known is the legend of Stingy Jack, a man supposedly too troublesome for both heaven and hell, left wandering the earth with nothing but a glowing ember inside a hollowed-out turnip. Whether Jack ever existed is beside the point, the story stuck.

When Irish and Scottish immigrants brought their traditions across the Atlantic during the nineteenth century, they found something rather convenient waiting for them: pumpkins. They were plentiful in North America during autumn, much larger than turnips and, most importantly for anyone who has ever tried hollowing out a root vegetable, a hell of a lot easier to work with.

So, the tradition adapted. The turnip slowly lost its starring role and the pumpkin took over. It already fitted naturally into the American autumn harvest season, and as Halloween celebrations grew, that big orange face became more and more recognizable. By the late nineteenth century, carved pumpkin lanterns were already appearing in Halloween celebrations and illustrations.

I love that there wasn’t really some grand pumpkin marketing meeting behind it. People carried an old tradition somewhere new, looked at what was available and basically went, Well, this works better.

And it worked so well that today the replacement has become more famous than the original. Ask someone to picture Halloween and chances are a pumpkin will show up somewhere in that picture. The turnip must be furious.

why are pumpkins associated with Halloween turnips
Image by jacqueline macou from Pixabay

Turns Out, You Can Eat the Decoration Too

My real introduction to pumpkin came much later, when I started working in professional kitchens. At first, I treated it pretty safely: garlic, rosemary, thyme, oregano, olive oil. Nothing wrong with that combination. But then my former chef Hans van Triest came along and started messing with my pumpkin world.

He introduced me to combinations and spices I hadn’t really connected with pumpkin before, especially Ras el hanout. The first time pumpkin and Ras el hanout really clicked for me, though, my brain went into its usual food-possibility mode. What else can I do with this? Apparently, quite a lot.

Spices got hotter, combinations became stranger and not every experiment deserved a second try. I overdid the heat more than once. But pumpkin with goat cheese became another combination that was welcomed with open arms, whether it was roasted, in a salad, little goat-cheese balls dropped into soup or turned into a cream alongside meat or fish. Once I knew two things worked together, my brain didn’t really accept that they should only work in one dish.

Cooking technique changes pumpkin too. Roast it and you get browning, moisture loss and deeper roasted flavors. Boil it and you get something softer and more delicate. But the pumpkin itself matters just as much. Different pumpkins contain different amounts of starch and pectin, which is one reason one pumpkin can give you a beautifully thick soup while another needs more help. It is something I learned to notice over the years. Sometimes the problem isn’t your soup. You just have a different pumpkin in the pot.

Maybe that is what kept pumpkin interesting to me after Hans opened that first door. There wasn’t one correct thing to do with it. Change the variety, technique, spices or what you put next to it, and it could become something completely different. Years later on Saba, I got to see another side of pumpkin completely. And that one started by throwing some seeds off a cliff.

When Pumpkin Came Looking for Me

Years later on Saba, I accidentally ended up growing my own pumpkins. After buying one from the local biological farm, I threw the seeds over the cliff behind my house, something I often did with leftover seeds. Usually nothing came from it. But this time, pumpkin vines appeared.

They grew down the cliff and eventually produced more pumpkins than I knew what to do with. They were big, with deep orange, dense flesh and a stronger flavor than many of the imported pumpkins I was used to. At first that was fantastic. After eating pumpkin for weeks, I was slowly starting to feel like a pumpkin myself.

Then my friend Piddy came over to pick up an old fridge I was giving him. He and his wife were known for their Saturday BBQ, selling chicken, pork and whatever sides and local produce they could get their hands on. While we were getting the fridge sorted, he spotted two big pumpkins further down the cliff. So, I told him if he wanted them he could go and get them because I wasn’t going down that cliff again.

He climbed down and came back up with two big pumpkins . I saw that he was genuinely happy with them. For me, that was enough. Sharing is caring, and at least I didn’t have to eat pumpkin for another week.

Then the following Saturday he surprisingly showed up at my house with two of their BBQ boxes, Chicken, pork, sides and right there among everything else was roasted pumpkin and a potato salad with pumpkin.

I had thrown some seeds off a cliff, accidentally grown pumpkins, given them away because I had eaten enough of them, and a week later they came back to me as dinner. Apparently, those pumpkins weren’t done with me yet.

why are pumpkins associated with Halloween vines
Image by t4no from Pixabay

More Than a Halloween Face

So why are pumpkins associated with Halloween? Mostly because people did what people have always done. They took an old tradition somewhere new, looked at what they had around them and adapted. The turnip had the job first, but the pumpkin turned out to be bigger, easier to carve and already perfectly at home in the autumn harvest. It did such a good job that somewhere along the way we almost forgot it was the replacement.

And I think that is the part I find most interesting. Something can become so connected to a tradition that it feels like it has always been there. But somewhere along the line, somebody had to look at a pumpkin and think, why not use this instead? Turns out, that wasn’t a bad idea.

Yohan