Let's get social!
smiling blonde woman standing with food over table
Back

That’s the Way (I Like It)

There is this saying that food always tastes better when someone else makes it. And every time I hear it, a small part of me thinks: Does it though?

Maybe I am just a difficult customer. I can be pretty picky when it comes to food, and after years of eating things that were badly cooked, not really my flavor, or simply not what I felt like eating, handing over control doesn’t automatically make my taste buds throw a little party. Sometimes I would much rather make it myself because then I know exactly what is going into the pan and, more importantly, what is coming out of it.

But the saying didn’t appear out of thin air either. There are definitely dishes that somehow seem better when somebody else puts them in front of us. Maybe it is because we didn’t have to do the work. Maybe it is the person who made it. Or perhaps something else sneaks onto the plate without us noticing.

So, why does food taste better when someone else makes it? The more I looked into that simple question, the less simple it became.

woman eating on cooking pan why does food taste better when someone else makes it
Photo by Juan Pablo Serrano on Pexels.com

But I Made It Myself

And here is where our little saying already starts wobbling. Because making food yourself can sometimes do the exact opposite of what we might expect: it can make you like it more.

There is even research behind this. When we put effort into making something ourselves, we can value the result more because we had a hand in creating it. Food isn’t immune to that little trick either. You chopped it, stirred it, tasted it, adjusted it, watched it slowly turn from a collection of ingredients into dinner. By the time it reaches the plate, there is already a little bit of “I made that” mixed in with the sauce.

But cooking can play another trick too. Sometimes all that smelling and tasting builds the excitement. One spoonful needs a little salt, another taste tells you the sauce is getting there, and suddenly you cannot wait to sit down and eat the finished dish. Other times, after smelling it, tasting it and adjusting it for the last hour, you finally put the plate down and think, You know what? I’m actually good.

I’ve experienced both plenty of times. Apparently, even cooking your own dinner refuses to pick a side in this argument.

Someone Else Cooked It or Someone Cooked It for You?

Maybe there is another little wrinkle hiding in that saying. There is a difference between someone else cooking the food and someone cooking the food for you. The first simply means you weren’t standing behind the stove. The second can come with care, attention and sometimes years of memories that nobody wrote down in the recipe.

Think about something as simple as chicken soup. If someone made it for you whenever you were sick as a kid, the smell alone can eventually carry more than chicken, vegetables and broth. Our brains are very good at learning associations between food, smells, people and situations. After enough repeats, that soup can become connected with being looked after, feeling safe or knowing that someone cared enough to make it for you. The soup hasn’t secretly developed an extra ingredient. You have.

I’ve got foods like that too. One of them is Robert’s wild mushroom risotto. He was brilliant at making risotto, and his version with Parmesan, mascarpone and little cubes of goose liver added at the end is still one of the best I’ve ever eaten. I’ve had plenty of risottos since, including in Italy, but that one still sits in a different place in my head.

And the funny part? Some of my best bites of it were eaten standing above a trash can during a busy dinner service. Not exactly the romantic Italian setting you would put on the postcard. Yet I can still almost taste that risotto when I think about it. Was it Robert’s technique? The ingredients? The relationship I had with him? The chaos around us? Probably some of all of it. Whatever the exact recipe was, not all of it was in the pan.

why does food taste better when someone else makes it
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.com

The Food Didn’t Change

We sometimes talk about taste as if it begins the moment food touches our tongue. But we don’t arrive at the plate as a blank page. We might be relaxed, excited, exhausted, stressed, angry or simply having one of those days when everything seems to be slightly annoying. And that can change how much pleasure we get from eating. The food doesn’t always have to change for the experience of eating it to change.

I learned that one rather quickly with a plate of pasta. I was cooking something I loved, had been tasting it along the way, and was genuinely looking forward to eating it. Then I got into a pretty aggressive argument with my employer. A few minutes earlier I had been hungry and excited about that pasta. After the argument, I sat down, took about two bites and pushed it away. There was nothing suddenly wrong with the dish. Nobody had sneaked into the kitchen during the argument and ruined my sauce. I had changed.

Mood and stress can affect appetite and how rewarding or enjoyable food feels, although not everybody reacts to them in the same way. For one person, a bad day can kill an appetite completely. For somebody else, food might be exactly what they reach for. Sometimes even something ridiculously simple can suddenly hit the right spot because of the moment you’re eating it in.

Which makes our original question even more slippery. We can give the same person the same dish on two different days and not necessarily give them the same experience. Apparently, there is quite a lot happening on the other side of the fork too.

Who Are You Cooking For?

People sometimes get nervous when they cook for me. Friends, colleagues, ex-girlfriends, even other chefs. Somewhere between knowing what I did for a living and putting the plate in front of me, dinner can accidentally turn into an exam I never asked them to take.

So, I usually tell them the same thing: make it how you like it and don’t worry about my opinion. I’m not sitting there with an invisible scorecard under the table. If you love your pasta with enough garlic to keep vampires out of the entire neighborhood, go for it. I’d much rather taste what you enjoy than something you nervously changed because you were trying to guess what I might approve of.

There are exceptions, though. A while ago I met Luis on the island I lived on, who I wrote about before when we explored arepas. He had no professional kitchen background, but the moment we started talking about arepas, his passion and knowledge were impossible to miss. This was his thing. He knew what he loved, and instead of being nervous about cooking for me, he was genuinely excited to share it. So, when he finally made an arepa for me, I didn’t tell him what toppings I wanted. I asked him to make his favorite. That was the arepa I wanted to taste.

And perhaps trust and expectation are closer to the plate than we think. What we’re told about food can influence how we experience it, sometimes before we’ve even taken a bite. I’ve spoken with chefs after they received Michelin recognition who told me that suddenly guests seemed to expect something more, even though the cooking and style that earned the recognition hadn’t magically changed overnight.

I’ve eaten disappointing food in very expensive restaurants and fantastic food in places where nobody was polishing the cutlery between courses. A Michelin star, a famous chef or a fancy dining room can certainly create expectations, but none of them can climb into your mouth and enjoy dinner for you.

Sometimes confidence comes from years behind a stove. Sometimes it comes from knowing one food so well that you cannot wait to share it. Luis had that with his arepas. And when somebody puts that kind of plate in front of me, I’m much more interested in tasting what they love than checking whether they cooked it the way I would.

why does food taste better when someone else makes it 2
Image by Fernando from Pixabay

Why Does Food Taste Better When Someone Else Makes It?

At first, the idea seems pretty logical. Someone else does the cooking, you sit down, the food arrives and somehow it tastes better. But the closer I looked at it, the more little things started getting in the way of such an easy answer.

Making food yourself can make you appreciate it more. Cooking can build your appetite or leave you feeling like you’ve already had enough by the time you sit down. Someone else cooking dinner isn’t quite the same as someone cooking for you. A bowl of soup can carry years of memories, while an argument can make a plate you were excited about suddenly lose its shine. Then there is trust, expectation, passion and whatever kind of mood you brought to the table that day.

None of this means the actual cooking doesn’t matter. Give me a beautifully cooked piece of fish and a dry, murdered one and I’m not going to blame the difference on childhood memories and my mood that day. Technique matters, ingredients matter, seasoning matters. But apparently, they don’t always come to the table alone.

And maybe that’s where I was looking in the wrong direction at the beginning. I wondered what the other person was doing that could make their food taste better. But it isn’t only about the person doing the cooking. The person doing the eating is bringing quite a lot to dinner as well.

So, why does food taste better when someone else makes it?

There isn’t one reason, because it doesn’t always taste better in the first place. Sometimes who made it matters, sometimes how it was made matters. And sometimes what happened before that first bite matters more than we realize. Which leaves me with a much less exciting answer than I expected when I started looking into all of this. But probably a more accurate one.

It depends. Two simple words for something that, once food and humans get mixed together, isn’t simple at all.

Yohan