Let's get social!
a man running on the snow
Back

“Take Me Home, Country Roads”

Summer is over. Well, that is according to quite a few people I have talked to lately. And unfortunately for me, the weather seems to agree with them. I don’t like the cold. Never have. The wind starts picking up, the first colder fronts enter the country again, jackets and coats are being pulled from wherever we threw them after spring, and slowly those long summer evenings start losing the fight against darkness. But I have to give autumn one thing: it smells pretty damn good.

This is the time of year when my kitchen starts changing. Stews find their way back onto the stove, hutspot and boerenkool suddenly sound like a good idea again, and the spices we call “warm” begin earning their name. Candles come out, fireplaces are cleaned, wood, gas, or just the one crackling away on the TV, and somehow sitting inside while the weather is being miserable outside starts feeling cozy instead of depressing. Well… slightly less depressing.

The chef in me notices another change too. September always meant the slow beginning of game season. Rich sauces, powerful spices, deeper flavors, beautiful seasonal produce and those hearty dishes that would have felt completely ridiculous a couple of months earlier suddenly start making sense again. Give me one dark, windy afternoon and apparently my brain is already standing beside a pot of stew with a wooden spoon in its hand. And I’m hardly alone.

As the days become colder and darker, many of us start reaching for food that feels warmer, fuller and somehow more comforting. Mashed potatoes instead of salad. Soup instead of something cold. A bubbling stew, a piece of bread to mop up the sauce and perhaps just a little too much gravy. Food that doesn’t merely fill your stomach but seems to do something else as well. We call it comfort food. But why? Why do we crave comfort food in winter?

why do we crave comfort food in winter 1
Image by Pirkko Seitsenpiste from Pixabay

Why Do We Crave Comfort Food in Winter?

There is actually a physical reason why colder weather can change what we feel like eating. Our bodies are rather fond of staying around the same temperature, and when we’re exposed to cold, keeping ourselves warm costs energy. One of the ways the body does this is through thermogenesis, which is basically a fancy word for producing heat. Cold exposure can increase how much energy we use and can influence appetite as well. Before you start using this as scientific permission to eat an entire lasagna because it’s raining, though, there is a small problem: most of us aren’t spending winter shivering in a cave anymore. We have heating, warm clothes, cars and houses. Your body may have to work a little harder in the cold, but it probably isn’t desperately begging you for 4,000 calories and a family-sized shepherd’s pie.

Still, walk through the door cold and hungry and tell me what sounds better: a cucumber or a steaming bowl of stew? Exactly. A lot of classic comfort foods pile several pleasurable things onto the same plate, warmth, fat, carbohydrates, salt, strong aromas and those soft, creamy or saucy textures that seem to belong to colder days. Even eating itself produces a little heat because digesting and metabolizing food costs energy. So, the body does have a seat at the comfort-food table. It just isn’t sitting there alone. And while science cannot officially confirm that winter requires gravy, I personally see no reason to take unnecessary risks.

The Whole Season Is Changing the Menu

But temperature is only part of the story. Winter doesn’t arrive carrying a thermometer and nothing else. The days get shorter, we see less daylight, we spend more time indoors, our activity and sleep can change, and for some people mood and energy change with it. Light is one of the signals that helps regulate our circadian rhythm, our internal clock, so when the amount of daylight changes, more than just the view outside the window changes. Appetite and eating behavior can shift along with that whole seasonal package.

And then there are all the little signals we have learned over the years. Rain against the window. Leaves changing color. The first pumpkins appearing in shops. Cinnamon suddenly multiplying everywhere as if it has been waiting patiently in a warehouse since March. We get the blankets out, spend more evenings inside and start seeing stews, pies and heavier dishes around us again. Sometimes the craving can even arrive before the real cold does, because our brains are very good at learning patterns and predicting what usually comes next. Autumn only has to play the first few notes and the brain already knows the rest of the song. Food, apparently, has seasonal playlists too.

That may also explain why the exact same food can feel different depending on the season. A crisp cold salad can be fantastic on a hot July afternoon. Put that same plate in front of me on a dark November evening while rain is hitting the windows, and somehow it has lost some of its charm. The salad hasn’t changed. The world around the plate has.

why do we crave comfort food in winter
Image by dauosshop from Pixabay

Comfortium Doesn’t Exist

So, if winter can nudge us toward certain foods, what actually turns one of them into comfort food? There is, unfortunately, no scientific compound called comfortium hiding inside mashed potatoes, although butter is doing its best. Comfort food isn’t really a category of food at all. It is a relationship between you and the food. Something can feel comforting because it is familiar, because you grew up with it, because somebody used to make it for you, or simply because your brain has learned that this particular smell, taste or dish belongs with a certain feeling.

That is also why comfort food looks completely different depending on where you grew up. For one person it might be mac and cheese, for another erwtensoep, rice and beans, chicken soup or even a bowl of plain rice. And here is where our winter theory gets interesting: people living in hot countries have comfort food too. You don’t need freezing rain and a radiator to want food that makes you feel safe or reminds you of home. So perhaps there are really two kinds of warmth hiding in this story. One is the warmth we have been talking about so far, the physical kind. The other has absolutely nothing to do with the temperature outside. And that second kind of warmth can start with something as simple as a smell.

That Smelly Pot of Hutspot

For me, one of those smells is hutspot. Potatoes, carrots and onions boiled or steamed together until they are soft enough to mash. Now, I would love to tell you that the smell of hutspot drifting through the house is one of the great aromas of Dutch cuisine, but that would be pushing it. Steamed onions aren’t exactly perfume. Yet I remember that smell from my childhood incredibly well. I knew what was coming: hutspot, my mother’s meatballs and, very importantly, lots of gravy. It was warm, filling and exactly the kind of food that belonged on a dark, cold day. The smell itself may not have been beautiful, but what came attached to it was.

Funny enough, I noticed that connection even more when I got older. I could be making hutspot myself or walk past a kitchen where somebody was preparing it for a staff dinner, and that familiar smell would hit my nose. Suddenly there was winter. There was hutspot. And somewhere behind it, there was childhood. Our sense of smell has particularly strong connections with areas of the brain involved in memory and emotion, which is one reason an aroma can bring back an autobiographical memory so quickly. But I don’t experience it as neurons firing or my brain opening an old filing cabinet. I smell cooked carrots and those slightly smelly onions, and for a moment an entire little world comes along with them. The food hasn’t travelled through time. I have.

why do we crave comfort food in winter 3
Image by Gedesby1989 from Pixabay

Comfort Can Begin Before Dinner

The funny thing about comfort food is that you don’t necessarily have to eat it before it starts working its magic. Think about a stew that has been bubbling away for a few hours. You walk through the door and smell it before you’ve even taken your coat off. Dinner might still be an hour away, but your brain already knows what is coming. The same can happen with coffee brewing, bread baking or onions frying in butter. Smell doesn’t just tell us what is in the kitchen; it can bring along expectation, memories and all the little associations we have collected around that food.

And sometimes the food is only one part of the ritual. That favorite mug you suddenly start using again when the evenings get colder. The blanket on the sofa. A bowl you always use for soup. Even cinnamon can do it. There is nothing inside cinnamon that scientifically says Christmas, but after years of smelling it around certain foods, places and celebrations, our brains become very good at connecting the dots. Eventually one small cue can wake up the whole picture. Maybe that is why comfort can begin at two in the afternoon when you think, I’m making stew tonight. Your stomach hasn’t received a single bite yet, but somewhere upstairs, dinner has already started.

The Ingredient No Chef Can Buy

This is also where chefs are at a bit of an unfair disadvantage. We can improve a recipe on paper. Better meat, better stock, better technique, seasoning adjusted perfectly, maybe a sauce that has been reduced for hours. And still somebody takes one bite and says, “It’s good, but my grandmother’s was better.” As a chef, there isn’t much you can do with that. You aren’t competing against another recipe anymore. You’re competing against a kitchen, a house, a Sunday afternoon, a voice, a smell, a person and perhaps a version of yourself that hasn’t existed for thirty years. Good luck putting all of that on your mise-en-place list.

Memory isn’t a perfect recording either. Every time we remember something, our brains reconstruct parts of it, which means that legendary stew from childhood may have received a little remastering over the years. Maybe Grandma really was a fantastic cook. Maybe she wasn’t. It almost doesn’t matter. Her food came seasoned with something no chef can order from a supplier: your life around it. The people who were there. Being looked after. Feeling safe. Belonging somewhere. Perhaps that is what we are sometimes really craving when we reach for comfort food, not simply the dish, but everything our brain has attached to it. And suddenly our winter craving has travelled quite a long way from being cold.

Yes, warmth matters. Smell matters. Fat, carbohydrates, texture and all those rich winter flavors can make food deeply satisfying. The darker days and colder weather can nudge us toward them. But somewhere along the way, physical warmth can become emotional warmth. A bowl of soup can carry a person. A smell can contain a kitchen you haven’t stood in for years. And a simple plate of mashed potatoes can hold far more than potatoes ever had any business carrying.

Maybe that is why the question underneath comfort food isn’t only What do I feel like eating? Sometimes it is something much simpler. What feels like home? Maybe comfort food doesn’t take us back home. Maybe, for a few bites, it brings home back to us.

Yohan