Let's get social!
Back

“More Than Words”

There is a phrase people use all the time. “That’s a bit vanilla.”

It usually describes something ordinary, safe, predictable. Nothing too exciting. Funny enough, that same ingredient also makes people ask another question. Why is vanilla so expensive?

Those two thoughts have never really made sense to me. How can something be called plain and precious at the same time?

The answer isn’t found in a supermarket bottle or a scoop of cheap vanilla ice cream. It’s found much deeper than that. Because somewhere along the way, we stopped getting to know vanilla. We simply got used to things that claimed to taste like it.

The first time I realized that was when I started working in professional kitchens. Until then, vanilla was something I knew from vanilla custard after dinner every now and then. It was pleasant enough, but nothing that really made me stop and think. Then I met the real thing. And suddenly I understood that those two products weren’t even distant relatives. They just happened to share the same name.

why vanilla is so expensive
Image by gate74 from Pixabay

More than one flavor

One thing that always surprises people is how different real vanilla tastes from the flavor they’ve known all their lives. Artificial vanilla isn’t necessarily bad. It simply tells a much shorter story.

Artificial vanilla always reminds me of someone trying just a little too hard. Open a bottle and the aroma almost jumps out to introduce itself.

Real vanilla doesn’t need an introduction. Real vanilla unfolds gently. It doesn’t rush, it doesn’t try to dominate everything around it. Instead, it quietly becomes part of the whole dessert. It knows you’ll find it.

Over the years I also learned that vanilla behaves differently depending on what you pair it with. Butter carries it beautifully through a cookie dough. Warm cream slowly coaxes flavor from both the seeds and the pod. Fat almost seems to understand vanilla’s language better than water ever could. Little details like that don’t sound very exciting. Until you taste the difference. Then they suddenly become everything.

The smell of respect

One of the first lessons I learned wasn’t how to cook with vanilla. It was how to respect it. Real vanilla pods weren’t something you casually left lying around in the kitchen. We kept them vacuum sealed to protect every bit of their aroma, and opening one of those bags almost became a little ritual.

The seal would break. The air escaped. And then it happened. It felt as if someone had burst a balloon filled with warmth and sweetness right in front of your face. Not an overpowering sweetness that demanded attention, but a soft, comforting aroma that quietly filled the room. Even before I touched a knife, I already knew I was holding something special.

Then came my favorite part. Cutting the pod open lengthwise. Running the back of the knife along the inside. Watching those tiny black seeds gather together into an almost oily paste instead of the dry little grains I had imagined years earlier. Every last seed was scraped out carefully.

Even then, the pod wasn’t finished. It still had one last job to do. Into the warm milk or cream it went, gently releasing whatever flavor still remained. Afterwards, it found a second life in a jar of sugar, slowly sharing the last of its aroma over the weeks that followed.

Nothing was wasted. Not because vanilla was expensive. Because it deserved the respect.

vanilla beans drying
Image by bigfoot from Pixabay

Why is vanilla so expensive?

Real vanilla isn’t expensive because somebody decided to put a high price tag on it. It’s expensive because nature didn’t make it easy.

Most people are surprised to learn that vanilla doesn’t grow on a tree or a bush. It actually comes from the fruit of an orchid, one of the very few orchids in the world that produces something edible. Even then, the flower only has a tiny window in which it can be pollinated. Outside its native habitat, that pollination is usually done by hand, flower by flower, by people who have become incredibly skilled at recognizing exactly the right moment. And that’s only the beginning.

The pods are picked while they’re still green. They don’t smell like vanilla yet. That familiar aroma develops slowly during months of curing, drying, sweating and resting. The pods are turned, checked and cared for over and over again until they finally become the soft, dark, fragrant vanilla pods we recognize in the kitchen.

By the time a good vanilla pod reaches a chef, hundreds of careful decisions have already been made by growers, farmers and producers. Every step matters. Rush one of them, and the quality suffers. Suddenly that little brown pod starts to look very different.

After learning all that, I stopped asking why vanilla is so expensive. I started wondering how we’ve ever convinced ourselves that it’s ordinary.

Master the classic first

Out of all the desserts I’ve made over the years, there’s one that will always deserve real vanilla. Crème brûlée.

I’ve made different versions throughout my career. The very first one I learned wasn’t even made with vanilla but with tonka beans. Later I learned the classic version with fresh Madagascan and Tahitian vanilla pods, gently infused into milk and cream before the mixture was strained and baked.

To me, that’s still the benchmark, not because other flavors aren’t delicious. They certainly can be. Coffee, chocolate, lavender, citrus, even herbs and spices can work beautifully. But only when the person making them truly understands what they’re changing.

Sometimes the classics don’t need improving. They need understanding first. Learn to master the original before you start reinventing it. Once you know your stuff, then go and play.

I’ve tasted plenty of crème brûlées where someone simply replaced the vanilla with another flavor and expected the recipe to do the rest. It rarely does. Every ingredient changes the balance. Some are sweeter, some add more bitterness, some bring acidity and others add richness. The cream-to-milk ratio, the sugar, even the baking time all need adjusting. A simple dessert isn’t always simple to make well. In fact, I’ve learned that the simplest dishes often leave the least room for mistakes.

creme brullee vanilla
Image by Rico k from Pixabay

Looking a little closer

The more I cooked, the more I realized something interesting. The ingredients people call “simple” are often the ones with the deepest stories. Bread, butter, salt and vanilla. There are still many more I want to mention but I will leave that for future posts.

We use vanilla so often that we stop asking questions. It quietly becomes part of everyday life until we forget that someone grew them, harvested them, learned to understand them and spent years mastering them. Vanilla taught me to slow down. Not while eating but while paying attention. Looking at the tiny seeds, the feeling the softness of a fresh pod.

Smelling the difference between something real and something trying very hard to imitate it. Those little moments changed the way I looked at ingredients. Maybe even the way I looked at people. Because people aren’t that different. The ones we think we already know often turn out to have the richest stories once we stop making assumptions and become curious enough to look a little closer.

More Than Words

Some ingredients quietly become victims of their own success. The more familiar they become, the less we seem to appreciate them. Vanilla might be the best example I know.

We taste it in ice cream, biscuits, cakes, custards and desserts from the moment we’re children. It’s everywhere, yet very few people ever stop to wonder what it really is, where it came from or why it deserves the respect it does. Maybe that’s why we’ve ended up calling ordinary things “vanilla.”

But I don’t think vanilla is ordinary at all. I think we’ve simply become surrounded by poor imitations for so long that we’ve forgotten what the real thing actually tastes like. People don’t call vanilla plain because vanilla is plain. They call it plain because they’ve only ever met poor imitations of it. That realization changed more than the way I looked at vanilla.

It changed the way I looked at ingredients altogether. The things we use almost every day often carry the longest stories. They quietly become part of our routine until we stop asking questions. We forget that someone planted them, cared for them, harvested them and spent years learning how to bring out the very best in them.

The familiar isn’t always simple. Sometimes it’s simply familiar. And there’s a world of difference between those two.

So, the next time someone says, “That’s a bit vanilla.” I hope you’ll smile for a moment before agreeing. Maybe you’ll picture that little orchid instead, or you’ll remember the people who pollinated it by hand. Maybe you’ll even think about the months of patience hidden inside one small brown pod. Or you’ll simply become a little more curious about the things you’ve known all your life.

Because sometimes the most familiar things are the ones we understand the least. And perhaps that’s exactly what makes them more than words.

Yohan